Catching up with reality

Markets have had an exhilarating run up over recent weeks.  Since the start of the month the S&P 500 has risen by close to 7%,gaining around 58% from its March low, as the evidence of global economic turnaround has strengthened and the outlook for earnings improved.

Nonetheless, the rally in equities has meant that valuations are starting to look stretched again. For instance the price / earnings ratio on the S&P 500 has risen to its highest level since January 2004, perhaps hinting at the need for a degree of investor caution in the days and weeks ahead.

Other factors aside from the pace of the move also call for some restraint to market optimism such as the potential for escalation in trade tensions between the US and China, the imposition of regulations on banks and the timing of reversal of extreme stimulus measures. 

As the panic has left markets over recent months volatility has eased as reflected in the VIX index which has dropped to around its lowest level since September 2008, just before it spiked massively higher in a matter of weeks in the wake of the Lehman’s blow up. 

This has been almost perfectly echoed in the move in currency volatility, which has dropped to around the levels last seen a year ago for major currencies.  These levels are not quite pre-crisis levels but for the most part pre-date the collapse of Lehman Brothers, reversing almost all the spike in risk aversion that took place from a year ago. 

It is probably not too much of a stretch to state that having expunged the shock of Lehmans and the worst fears about the global economy from measures of risk and volatility the room for further improvements may be somewhat more limited.  This may be countered by the fact that economic data continues to deliver positive surprises relative to consensus, providing fuel for a further rally in risk appetite. 

However, a lot of good news must surely be in the price by now and it is likely that even the most bearish of forecasters has to acknowledge that an upswing in activity is underway. This ought to ensure that consensus forecasts catch up with reality, leaving less room for positive surprises and perversely less support for equity markets. 

The rally in risk appetite and equity markets has taken its toll on the US dollar which has had a gruelling few weeks during which the US dollar index (a basket of currencies versus USD including EUR, JPY, GBP, CAD, SEK and CHF) has hit new lows almost on daily basis.  Any pause in dollar selling driven by a softer tone to equities is likely to provide better opportunities for investors to take short positions in the currency given that little else has changed in terms of USD sentiment.   How far can the dollar drop?  Well for a start the April 2008 low around 71.329 for the USD index beckons and after that its into uncharted territory.

Contrasting messages from bonds, gold and equities

There is an interesting divergence developing between bond yields, gold prices and the trend in equity markets.  Whilst equities continue to go up, bond yields are falling and gold prices are rising.  Indeed the usually strong relationship between the S&P 500 and US 10 year yields has collapsed to an insignificant correlation around -0.09 over the past month compared to a high correlation of 0.84 in the month to 8 August.  

Rising equities appear to signify an improvement in risk appetite whilst bonds (US 10-year yield around 3.4%) and gold (around $1000 per troy ounce) are giving the opposite message.  So which indicator is correct and why the breakdown in the usually solid relationship?  

Growing optimism about economic recovery and the run of better than forecast data releases suggest that equities are correct but there is growing risk that so much good news is now priced in that we should pay attention to what bond yields and gold prices are telling us.  

Some of the move lower in bond yields can probably be attributed to the wall of liquidity sloshing around due to central banks’ unconventional policy measures.  However, it is still remarkable that despite the plethora of better than expected data releases, bond yields have actually declined.  This may reflect the success of quantitative easing but could also be associated with sustained economic and market fears.    

The commitment by G20 officials last weekend not to reverse stimulus policies prematurely may also have given more confidence in the view that interest rates will not be raised quickly.  Reflecting this 2 year German bund yields dropped to a record low level at the beginning of the week although longer term bond yield have pushed higher in the 30 year area.  The G20 commitment could turn out to be a double edged sword, however.  If there is no commitment to reduce burgeoning deficits, bonds could ultimately take fright.  

If bonds and gold prices are really reflecting safe haven demand then it will pose a risk to the sustainability of any equity rally over coming months.  As equity valuations begin to look increasingly stretched – the P/E ratio on the S&P 500 has reached 18.76 (according to Bloomberg calculations) compared to a low of around 10.00 at the beginning of March 2009 – it will need more to keep the rally going and high amongst the factors needed is some clarity about the pace and shape of growth once stimulus is reversed. 

For currency markets I think it will be difficult to see a trend until there is more clarity about the economic outlook and in the meantime currency markets will continue to stock watch for direction even if the influence of risk appetite is declining.  Even so, the dollar appears to be reacting more to equities than bond movements and is coming under growing pressure as equities rise.  

Many currencies are poised to break out of recent ranges to the topside versus the dollar led by risk currencies such as the AUD, NZD and CAD.  If it turns out that the equity story rather than the bond message is the correct one then the real message is a bullish one for risk appetite and given the dollar’s usually negative reaction to improved risk appetite, it could face further pressure over coming weeks.