Sell Risk Trades On Rallies

It seems that every time there is a bounce in risk appetite it quickly dissipates as worries about growth, fiscal deficits, sovereign debt, etc, return to dent sentiment. This was again the case overnight as markets sold off late in the US session, with an early bounce in sentiment proving too fragile to last. This pattern of trading is set to persist for a long while yet, with the overall tone of selling risk trades on rallies remaining in place.

Fears over a double dip global recession have increased since the release of Friday’s disappointing US jobs report even if it is too early to pass judgment based on the basis of one month’s data. Coupled with worries about slowing growth momentum in China, hopes that slower growth in the eurozone could be counterbalanced by firm growth elsewhere are being dashed. The problem is that despite a strong quarter of growth for most economies in Q2 2010 the outlook for the second half of the year is far more uncertain.

European Union officials sought to calm worries about the potential for renewed fiscal crises in the future by agreeing to monitor national budgets more closely and at an earlier stage whilst introducing a wider range of sanctions on excessive deficits. Unfortunately this is akin to the idiom about closing the stable door after the horse has bolted. The steps aren’t going to help resolve the current crisis. Evidence of implementation, execution and results on the deficit cutting front will help however, but this is a process that will take months rather than days or weeks.

A couple of factors may have prevented the EUR from extending losses overnight. 1) Germany announced EUR 80 billion in spending cuts along with 15,000 public sector job cuts. Germany also is pushing for a financial transactions tax on tap of the bank levy. 2) European finance ministers finalised details of the EUR 440 bn Financial Stability Facility which aims to sell AAA rated bonds to make loans to eurozone countries. The only question is the approval process. The statement on the funds operations only said that “national legal procedures to participate in the facility are well on track”. EUR/USD is likely to range between 1.1826 and 1.2110 over the short-term.

Euro Has That Sinking Feeling

The reaction to the US May jobs report shows that markets are particularly susceptible to negative US news at a time when growth fragilities in Europe are becoming increasingly apparent. Coupled with worries about Hungary, risk aversion has jumped.

Unsurprisingly the EUR took the brunt of pressure. Rhetoric over the weekend may help to assuage some fears but I suspect it is too late now that the cat is out of the bag. Hungary’s government maintained that it will meet this year’s budget deficit target of 3.8% of GDP. European Union officials also attempted to calm market concerns, downplaying any comparison of Hungary to Greece.

The overall EUR/USD downtrend remains intact. Renewed doubts about German participation in the EU/IMF rescue package, with the German constitutional court potentially blocking its contribution, will add to pressure as well as a UK press report titled EUR ‘will be dead in five years’ . The January 1999 EUR/USD introduction level around 1.1830 has now moved squarely into sight.

It is unlikely that data and events this week will do much to reverse the market’s bearish tone. Highlights include the ECB, BoE and RBNZ meetings in Europe, UK and New Zealand, respectively. The ECB (Thursday) is highly unlikely to shift its monetary policy stance. Given some opposition to bond purchases from within the ECB council the comments in the accompanying statement will be closely monitored. The BoE will also leave policy unchanged on the same day but the RBNZ is set to begin its hiking cycle with a 25bps move.

On the data front the US slate includes the Fed’s Beige Book, April trade data, May retail sales and June Michigan confidence. The Beige Book is likely to reveal some improvement in activity with little sign of inflation, whilst the trade deficit is set to widen further due to a higher oil import bill. Retail sales will reveal an autos led increase in the headline reading but more subdued core sales, whilst consumer confidence is set to rise for a second straight month.

There will be more attention on rhetoric from EU officials rather than eurozone data, with the Eurogroup of Finance Minister’s and Ecofin meetings garnering more interest. In Japan, politics will take centre stage, with the new cabinet line up in focus following the confirmation of Naoto Kan as Prime Minister. Comments by the new PM himself will be of interest, especially with regard to combating deflation and in particular any elaboration on his penchant for a weaker JPY.

All-in-all, the week is unlikely to see a let up in pressure on risk trades and will start much as the last week ended. Although the market’s attention is on the EUR, it should be noted that the AUD has lost even more ground so far this month although the EUR remains the biggest loser in terms of major currencies so far this year (vs USD). In the case of the AUD the move reflects a massive unwinding of long positioning (as reflected in the latest CFTC IMM data which shows that speculative AUD positioning has dropped to its lowest since March 2009).

In contrast in the case of the EUR where positioning is already very negative, the move simply reflects deteriorating fundamentals. The fact that European officials are showing little concern about the decline in the EUR (why should they given that the currency is now trading around fair value) and in some cases encouraging it, suggests that there is little to stop EUR/USD from dropping much further and parity is looming a lot closer.

What A Disappointment!

Ok so after talking up US data releases over recent weeks the big one namely the May jobs report, came as a disappointment. To recap, payrolls rose 431k, which was less than market consensus. Hiring due to the census which by its nature will be transitory was however, in line with expectations, at 411k, leaving ex-census hiring at a measly +20k.

Believe it or not, the trend in payrolls is one of improvement but the May outcome came as a blow to a market with bullish expectations, especially following earlier comments from the US administration hinting at a robust outcome. The disappointment was compounded by talk of a +700k payrolls outcome, which proved widely off the mark. The unemployment rate did drop more than expected, by two ticks to 9.7%, but this was due to disaffected workers dropping out of the labor force rather than an inherent pick up in job conditions.

Combined with worries about a new target in the sovereign debt crisis in Europe, this time Hungary, markets quickly tanked and risk aversion jumped. So much for relative stability! The concerns were sparked by Hungarian officials themselves, with a spokesman for the Prime Minister warning about the fiscal mess inherited from the previous government. The real blow came when the spokesman compared Hungary to Greece and reportedly said that talk of a default was “not an exaggeration”.

Suffice to say, markets are set up for tense and nervous week in which risk trades are set to suffer further. EUR/USD once again proved to be the weak link dropping below the psychologically important level of 1.20 and the EUR introduction rate around 1.1830 has moved sharply into focus.

Renewed concerns

Despite some positive US data, with both the May ISM manufacturing index and April construction spending coming in stronger than forecast, market sentiment soured. The relative calm that was exhibited at the end of May is giving way to renewed fears as equity markets weaken, volatility increases and risk aversion intensifies. Risk trades are set to remain on the back foot, with the EUR likely to remain the weakest link. After testing support close to 1.2110 EUR/USD bounced but remains vulnerable to a fresh test of this level in the short-term.

A combination of concerns including rumours of ratings downgrades, with France the new target, Middle East tensions, weaker Chinese manufacturing activity and worries about increasing bank writedowns in Europe, have conspired to drag markets lower. The failure to stem the hue oil-leak in the US contributed to the malaise as the US government announced a criminal probe.

For the most part, data releases were unhelpful to risk appetite as the majority of global purchasing managers indices (PMIs) slipped in May, led by China. Only a few increased, including India and notably Ireland, whilst the Spanish and Greek PMIs fell. Although the US ISM index slipped the components looked positive, especially the employment component which moved higher, suggesting some upside potential for Friday’s May payrolls data for which we look for a 500k increase.

A picture of divergence appears to be growing in the eurozone, which will act as another source of pressure on the EUR. Germany’s outperformance is widening as reflected by the fact the German unemployment dropped to 7.7% in May in contrast to a rise in eurozone unemployment, to 10.1%. Moreover, Germany was the only country where its PMI was actually revised higher relative to the flash reading. There are also growing divisions within the European Central Bank (ECB), in particular towards the purchase of government bonds, with German ECB members particularly critical.

Switching risk on and off

There are several words that can be used to describe current highly risk averse market dynamics including panicked, nervous, fickle, tense, jittery, risky, volatile etc, all of which spark negative thoughts in the minds of investors. Aside from real worries such as renewed banking sector concerns, especially in Europe and in particular with regard to Spanish savings banks, there are also plenty of rumours afflicting market sentiment. In this environment deriving fact from fiction is not particularly easy whilst battling against the heavy weight of negative sentiment.

Although the pull back in risk appetite over recent weeks looks small compared to the peak in risk aversion during the financial crisis, the pace of the drop in markets has been dramatic and the withdrawal of risk seeking capital has been particularly aggressive. For example, in less than one month Asian equity markets have registered an outflow of around half of the total equity capital flows so far this year. Worryingly and despite the backstop in terms of central bank liquidity provision there are signs of renewed tensions in the money markets, with the libor-OIS spread and TED spread widening over recent days.

One of the most interesting observations in the current environment is that risk aversion has been increasing despite encouraging economic data. Not only has economic data been positive but in general has been coming in above consensus, showing that the market has underestimated the bounce in growth in the second quarter. Why is positive data not soliciting a more positive market reaction? Recent data is perhaps being seen as backward looking, and there is growing concern about the likely downdraft on economic activity in H2 2010, especially in Europe as deficit cutting measures bite.

News on the budget front in Europe has been relatively positive too, with Greece registering a sharp decline in its deficit, as well as announcing plans to tighten tax administration procedures. Meanwhile, the Italian cabinet reportedly approved a package of measures to reduce its deficit. On the flip side budget cuts across Europe are leading to growing public opposition, testing the resolve of eurozone governments to pass austerity measures. The public opposition means that the real test is in the implementation and execution of austerity measures. Signs of progress on this front will be key to turn confidence in the EUR around.

The USD remains king in the current environment and any pull back is likely to be bought into though Moody’s ratings agency’s warnings that the US AAA sovereign rating may come under pressure if there was no improvement in the US fiscal position, highlights the risks over the medium term to this currency. The EUR is set to remain under pressure though it is worth noting that the pace of its decline appears to be slowing, leaving open the potential for some consolidation. Near-term technical support for EUR/USD is seen at 1.2142 but a broader range of around 1.18.23-1.2520 is likely to develop over coming weeks.