Money Printing

It was a day of surprises on Tuesday as the Bank of Japan (BoJ) not only created a JPY 5 trillion fund to buy domestic assets including JGBs but also cut interest rates to zero. Expect more measures to come in the fight against a stronger JPY and deflation. The Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) also surprised markets by leaving its policy rate unchanged at 4.5% delaying another rate hike yet again despite expectations by many including ourselves of a 25bps rate hike.

The easier policy stance from the BoJ and RBA taken together with firmer service sector purchasing managers indices – including the September US ISM non-manufacturing survey, which came in at 53.2 from 51.5 – gave risk appetite a solid lift. Even the AUD which dropped sharply following the RBA decision, managed to recoup all of its losses and more overnight.

Japan’s decision could have set the ball rolling for a fresh round of quantitative easing (QE) from central banks as they combat sluggish growth prospects ahead and ongoing deflation risks. The US Fed as has been much speculated on and the Bank of England (BoE) are likely candidates for more QE. Whilst the European Central Bank (ECB) is unlikely to adopt such measures there are reports that board members are split over the timing of exit policy. The BoE decision on Thursday may provoke more interest than usual against this background although the Bank is unlikely to act so quickly. The Fed on the other hand appears to be gearing up for a November move.

Growing prospects of fresh QE looks likely to provide further impetus for risk trades. Notably commodity prices jumped higher, with the CRB commodities index at its highest level since the beginning of the year. Although there is plenty of attention on the gold price which yet a fresh record high above $1340 per troy ounce as well as tin which also hit new highs, the real stars were soft commodities including the likes of sugar, coffee and orange juice up sharply.

The main loser once again is the US dollar and this beleaguered currency appears to be finding no solace, with any rally continuing to be sold into, a pattern that is set to continue. Although arguably a lot is in the price in terms of QE expectations, clearly the fact that the USD continues to drop (alongside US bond yields) highlights that a lot does not mean that all is in the price.

The USD is set to remain under pressure against most currencies ahead of anticipated Fed QE. The fact that the USD has already dropped sharply suggests a less pronounced negative USD reaction once the Fed starts buying assets but the currency is still set to retain a weaker trajectory once the Fed USD printing press kicks into life again as a simple case of growing global USD supply will push the currency weaker.

USD weakness will only spur many central banks including across Asia to intervene more aggressively to prevent their respective currencies from strengthening. A “currency war” looms, a fact that could provoke some strong comments at this weekend’s IMF and World Bank meetings. In the meantime intervention by central banks will imply more reserves recycling, something that will continue to benefit currencies such as EUR and AUD.

Speculators bail out of USDs

Risk appetite held up reasonably well last week, with markets failing to be derailed by concerns over Ireland’s banking sector and growing opposition to austerity measures across Europe. The main loser remained the USD, with the USD index hitting a low marginally above 78.00 and speculative positioning as reflected in the CFTC IMM data revealing a further sharp drop in sentiment to its lowest since Dec 2007.

This week is an important one for central bank meetings, with four major central banks deliberating on monetary policy including Bank of Japan (BoJ), Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA), European Central Bank (ECB) and Bank of England (BoE). The major event of the week however, is Friday’s release of the September US employment report. The RBA is set to hike its cash rate by 25bps, the BoJ may announced more easing measures whilst in contrast both the ECB and BoE are unlikely to alter their policy settings.

Whilst the BoJ is widely expected to leave its policy rate unchanged at 0.1%, it may announce further measures against the background of persistent JPY strength, a worsening economic outlook as reflected in last week’s Tankan survey and decline in exports. Japanese press indicate that the BoJ may increase lending of fixed rate 3 to 6 month loans to financial institutions as well as buy more short-term government debt.

The measures alongside risks of further JPY intervention may prevent USD/JPY slipping further but as reflected in the increase in speculative net long JPY positions last week, the market is increasingly testing the resolve of the Japanese authorities. Strong support is seen around USD/JPY 82.80, with the authorities unlikely to allow a break below this technical level in the short-term.

Although we will only see details of the voting in two weeks in the release of the UK BoE Monetary Policy Commitee (MPC) minutes it is likely that there was a three-way split within the MPC as reflected in recent comments, with MPC member Posen appearing to favour more quantitative easing whilst the MPC’s Sentance is set to retain his preference for higher rates. As has been the case over recent months the majority of the MPC are likely to have opted for the status quo.

GBP was a laggard over September as markets continued to fret over potential QE from the BoE. This uncertainty is unlikely to fade quickly suggesting limited gains against the USD and potentially more downside against the EUR. GBP speculative sentiment has improved but notably positioning remains short. EUR/GBP will likely target resistance around 0.8810.

In contrast to GBP the EUR has taken full advantage of USD weakness and looks set to extend its gains. Although there is a risk that speculative positioning will soon become overly stretched it is worth noting that positioning is well below its past highs according to the IMM data. EUR may have received some support from Chinese Premier Wen’s pledge to support Greece, and a stable EUR. Whilst there continues to be risks to the EUR from ongoing peripheral debt concerns such comments likely to be repeated at the EU-Asia summit today and tomorrow, will keep the EUR underpinned for a test of 1.3840.

USD pressure, EUR resilience, GBP whipsawed

Speculation the Fed will begin a new program of asset purchases or QE2 as soon as November is intensifying. The weaker than expected reading for US consumer confidence in September released on Tuesday has only added to this expectation as sentiment continues to be hit by job market concerns. Against this background the USD remains under strong downward pressure, with little sign of any turnaround.

The prospects of further USD debasing as well as intervention in many countries to prevent their currencies from strengthening against the USD continues to power gold prices which hit a new record high having breezed through the $1300 per troy ounce mark. In the current environment it is hard to see gold prices turning much lower although there may be some risk of profit taking in the weeks ahead.

The EUR remains a key beneficiary of USD weakness but this currency has problems of its own to contend with. Indeed, peripheral debt concerns, especially with regard to Ireland and to a lesser extent Portugal have increased, with borrowing costs rising as the yield on their debt widens against core eurozone debt. The stronger EUR will only make it harder for these countries to achieve any sort of recovery and could also damage the stronger exporting countries of Northern Europe led by Germany.

So far however, the EUR has managed to show some impressive resilience to renewed peripheral country sovereign debt concerns including comments by S&P about the high costs of rescuing an Irish Bank. Perhaps the knowledge that there is a still a huge bailout fund from the EU and IMF available if needed and also the prospect that the ECB will increase its buying of eurozone debt, has provided a buffer for the EUR.

At some point the ECB may be forced to join the battle in at least attempting to talk its currency lower but at this stage the central bank is showing no inclination to either talk down the currency or physically intervene to weaken the EUR. In the meantime, EUR/USD is likely to strengthen further despite the likely negative impact on European growth, with the currency likely to set its sights on an eventual break above 1.40.

One currency that may struggle in the wake of expectations of Fed QE2 is GBP. Uncertainty over whether the Bank of England will follow the Fed in implementing further quantitative easing could see GBP lag the gains in other currencies against the USD. Conflicting comments from MPC members Posen who noted that there may be a need for further QE in the UK to support the faltering economy were countered by Sentance who noted that there was no need for more QE. GBP/USD is likely be whipsawed as the debate continues and is set to lose further ground against the EUR.

FX Tension

On September 22 1985 the governments of France, West Germany, Japan, US and UK signed the Plaza Accord which agreed to sharply weaken the USD. At this time it was widely agreed that the USD was overly strong and needed to fall sharply and consequently these countries engineered a significant depreciation of the USD.

It is ironic that 25 years later governments are once again intervening in various ways and that the USD is once again facing a precipitous decline as the Fed moves towards implementing further quantitative easing. This time central banks are acting unilaterally, however, and there is little agreement between countries. For instance Japan’s authorities found no help from the Fed or any other central bank in its recent actions to buy USD/JPY.

So far Japan’s FX interventions have been discreet after the initial USD/JPY buying on 15 September. The fact that Japan is less inclined to advertise its FX intervention comes as little surprise given the intensifying pressure from the US Congress on China for not allowing its currency, the CNY to strengthen. Tensions have deepened over recent weeks and the backing of a bill last week by an important Congressional committee to allow US companies to seek tariffs on Chinese imports suggests that the situation has taken a turn for the worse.

The softly softly approach to Japan’s FX intervention and US/China friction reflects the fact that unlike in 1985 we may be entering a period in which currency and in turn trade tensions are on the verge of intensifying sharply against the background of subdued global economic recovery.

The Fed’s revelation that it is moving closer to implementing further quantitative easing has shifted the debate to when QE2 occurs rather than if, with a November move moving into focus. Clearly the USD took the news negatively and will likely remain under pressure for a prolonged period as the simple fact of more USD supply weighs heavily on the currency. Markets will be able to garner more clues to the timing of QE2, with a plethora of Fed speakers on tap over coming days.

This week the US economic news will be downbeat, with September consumer and manufacturing confidence surveys likely to register declines, with consumer sentiment weighed down by the weakness in job market conditions. Personal income and spending will also be of interest and gains are expected for both. There will be plenty of attention on the core PCE deflator given that further declines could give clues to the timing of QE2.

Attention in Europe will centre on Wednesday’s recommendations for legislation on “economic governance” from the European Commission. Proposed penalties for fiscal indiscipline may include withholding of funding and/or voting restrictions but such measures would be politically contentious. Measures to enforce fiscal discipline ought to be positive for markets given the renewed tensions in peripheral bond markets in the eurozone.

The EUR was a major outperformer last week benefiting from intensifying US QE speculation and will set its sights on technical resistance (20 April high) around 1.3523 in the short-term. Notably EUR speculative positioning has turned positive for the first time this year according to the CFTC IMM data, reflecting the sharp shift in speculative appetite for the currency over recent weeks. The EUR has been surprisingly resilient to renewed sovereign debt concerns and similarly softer data will not inflict much damage to the currency this week.

Ready for Fed QE2

The USD was already under pressure ahead of the Fed FOMC decision last night, with the EUR benefiting in particular from successful debt auctions in Ireland and Spain. The Fed statement resulted in a further lurch lower for the USD index as it fell through the 81.00 level on its way to testing the August low of 80.09. EUR/USD broke important technical resistance levels moving above its 200-day moving average (1.3215). In contrast, gold prices continued to surge hitting a new record high whilst 2-year Treasury yields fell to an all-time low.

The US Federal Reserve confirmed that it was ready to ease if needed. Although the decision to leave the Fed funds target rate at 0% to 0.25% unchanged and commitment to maintain exceptionally low levels of the rate for an “extended period” came as no surprise there was a subtle change in the language of the statement regarding further easing. The Fed noted that it was “prepared to provide additional accommodation if needed” a shift from the previous wording that it “will employ its tools as necessary”.

It appears to be a case of not if but when the Fed embarks on further quantitative easing and/or other policy accommodation. Once again the Fed offered no guideposts to determine the timing of easing and the decision will ultimately be data dependent. Nonetheless, the bias has clearly shifted towards more balance sheet expansion.

We expect core inflation to decline further over the coming months although we do not forecast a drop to as low as 0.5%. Nonetheless, declining core CPI could lead to the Fed’s disinflation concerns intensifying. Indeed, providing further rationale for the Fed’s conditional easing bias was the particularly dovish stance on inflation in the FOMC statement.

If it wasn’t obvious before it has become increasingly clear now that the USD will not relinquish its role as the ultimate funding currency for a long time to come. Although interest rate differentials are not yet the main driver for most currency pairs, with risk aversion retaining this role for now, there is a very high correlation between certain high yielding currencies and their respective interest rate differentials against the USD.

For instance, there is a high and significant correlation between interest rate differentials between Japan, Australia, Canada and the US and their respective currency pairs. AUD/USD is one to watch as the currency hit a fresh 25 month high overnight. Although the AUD looks rich at current levels, the shift in relative yield with the US overnight provides a further underpinning to the currency, with parity being talked about once again.

Even USD/JPY moved lower in the wake of the Fed statement dropping just below 85.00 although the threat of further official Japanese FX intervention will likely prevent a sharp drop in the currency pair. It will be interesting to see how far the market is prepared to go, with further threats of FX intervention by Prime Minister Kan overnight. Despite the threats the narrowing in US / Japan bond yields overnight suggests more downside pressure on USD/JPY and a fresh challenge for the Japanese authorities.