Calming the Tiger

February 17, 2010 — Mitul Kotecha

As markets enter the year of the Tiger a somewhat calmer tone appears to be ensuing, with risk appetite edging higher helping equities and the beleaguered EUR to recover some lost ground.  US stocks were helped by a firmer than expected reading for the Empire manufacturing survey (to 24.91 in Feb) and a slight uptick in the US NAHB (National Association of Home Builders) index (to 17 in Feb) but consumer confidence remained weak as indicated by the decline in the weekly reading of ABC Consumer Confidence (-49).  

On the other side of the pond the better than expected February ZEW survey (a survey of investor confidence) in Germany (45.1) helped sentiment although it still recorded a decline from the previous month as Greek fiscal/debt concerns weighed on financial market participants’ confidence.  The bigger impetus came from comments by Greek Finance Minister Papaconstantinou who said there would be no need to for a bailout of the country.

Tensions over Greece eased further following news that tax collectors in the country called off a planned strike, helping to allay some concerns that unions will block planned spending cuts.   On the policy front, the EU Council ratified Greece’s plans but with strings attached, giving the country one month to present a report on the timetable for implementing budget cuts for 2010 and three months to outline policy measures required to cut the deficit below 3% by 2012.

Meanwhile, commodity prices have pushed higher helping currencies such as the AUD and NZD to strengthen.  Moreover, the AUD was boosted by more hawkish interest rate expectations following the release of the minutes of the latest RBA policy meeting which indicated that the Reserve Bank was merely pausing in its rate cycle.  Expectations of a rate hike in March increased as a result.

Overall, the recent rally in the USD is looking increasingly overdone and some reversal is likely over coming weeks.  The fact that market positioning has reached extreme levels in particular in the case of the EUR highlights scope for some recovery in the currency, especially now that the worst case scenario of a Greek default has passed.  The outlook for commodity currencies is even more bullish as risk appetite improves further.     

If anything, data today is likely to give further support to the recovery story, with US industrial production and housing starts expected to post healthy gains.  The Fed FOMC minutes may offer some additional insight into the debate over the implementation of exit strategies but there is unlikely to be much elaboration from the recent comments by Fed Chairman Bernanke in his speech to the US Senate in which he hinted that a rise in the discount rate is not far off.  

Risk currencies including many Asian currencies are likely to benefit from the improvement in risk appetite over the short term.  EUR/USD will likely strengthen as more short positions are covered but will face strong technical resistance around 1.3839.   Asian currencies have been resilient to the recent rise in risk aversion and this is likely to continue over the coming weeks.  As risk appetite recovers currency plays including long AUD/JPY , and even some further upside in EUR/USD look favourable.

Posted in Asia, Australia, central banks, Commodities, Currencies, Economics, Economy, emerging markets, equity markets, Europe, Financial crisis, Fiscal/Budget, FX, Germany, Greece, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

Tarnishing The Euro

February 11, 2010 — Mitul Kotecha

I am just finishing up a client trip in Japan and waiting to take a flight back to Hong Kong. The time ahead of the flight has allowed some reflection on my meetings here. One thing that has been particularly evident is the strong interest in all events European. Some I have spoken to have wondered out loud whether this the beginning of the end of the European project.  At the least it is evident that fiscal/debt problems in Greece and elsewhere in Europe have tarnished the image of the EUR.

Markets continue to gyrate on any news about Greece and the potential for support from the Europe Union and/or IMF. The divergent views between European countries about how to deal with the problem has intensified, suggesting that reaching an agreement will not be easy. Some countries including the UK and Sweden have suggested enrolling the help of the IMF but this has been resisted by other European countries. Germany and France are trying to rally support ahead of today’s crucial meeting of European officials.

The EUR reacted positively to news that some form of support package is being considered but nothing concrete has appeared yet, leaving markets on edge. The EUR has been heavily sold over recent weeks; speculative market positioning reached a record low in the latest week’s CFTC Commitment of Traders’ IMM report. The fact that EUR positioning has become so negative suggests that the EUR could rebound sharply in the event that some support package for Greece is announced.

Any package will not come without strings attached, however, as European officials will want to avoid any moral hazard. A couple of options hinted at by German officials include fresh loans or some form of plan to purchase Greek debt. Either way, any solution to Greece’s problems will not be quick and will likely result in a sharp contraction in economic activity as the government cuts spending especially as Greece does not have the option of the old remedy of devaluing its currency. Meanwhile, strikes and social tensions in the country could escalate further. A solution for Greece will only constitutes around 2.5% of eurozone GDP will also not prevent focus from continuing to shift to Portugal, Spain and other countries with fiscal problems despite comments by Moody’s ratings agency to differentiate between the countries.

Even if the EUR rebounds on any positive news about support for Greece any relief is likely to prove temporary and will provide better levels to sell into to play for a medium term decline in the currency. Ongoing fiscal concerns, a likely slower pace of economic recovery, divergencies in views of European officials, and the fact that the EUR is still overvalued suggests that the currency will depreciate over much of 2010, with a move to around EUR/USD 1.30 or below in prospect over coming months.

Posted in Bond markets, Currencies, Economics, Economy, Europe, Financial crisis, Fiscal/Budget, FX, Germany, Greece, Japan. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

What To Watch This Week

February 7, 2010 — Mitul Kotecha

As usual the G7 meeting will leave markets with little to chew on. G7 officials maintained their commitment to stimulus measures and timely exit strategies but there was little of note for FX markets aside from the usual comments about wanting to avoid excess FX volatility. There was certainly know step up in pressure on China to strengthen though a report prepared for the meeting did push for countries with inflexible currencies to make adjustments. Meanwhile US officials mouthed the usual “strong dollar” mantra.

Where does this leave markets this week? Well I must admit my bullish view on risk currencies is clearly suffering after a positive start to the year. The pullback in high beta currencies (those with the highest sensitivity to risk aversion) has been dramatic. I have highlighted many of the factors weighing on sentiment in previous posts and whilst I still think the US dollar will find itself under renewed pressure over coming months the current environment remains conducive to more USD and JPY buying and selling of currencies such as the AUD, NZD, CAD, GBP, NOK, SEK, ZAR etc.

Ironically the US and Japan have arguably more severe deficit/debt concerns than some of the European countries under pressure but as most of Japan’s debt is held domestically there is little worry of a collapse in JGBs. Unlike Japan foreign investors hold over half of US debt but are not yet losing confidence with US Treasuries though this may not last unless there is some tangible sign that the burgeoning US budget deficit is being reduced. For now, attention remains firmly focussed on Greece, Spain, Portugal and to a lesser extent Italy.

Like the G7 meeting the US January jobs report released at the end of last week will give little direction for markets. Although the 20k drop in payrolls and revisions to past months were slightly disappointing the surprise drop in the unemployment rate was better news. This week’s data highlights include the January US retail sales report and December trade balance. The sales data is likely to help allay some concerns about faltering economic recovery, with retail sales forecast to rise over the month despite a likely pull back in autos spending.

How will this play out for currencies this week? Overall, the risk off tone is set to continue though the moves are looking increasingly stretched. The USD, JPY and CHF will remain on the front foot whilst risk currencies will remain under pressure. The EUR is set to continue to struggle against the background of eurozone deficit concerns and after its dive through 1.40 last week 1.35 now looms large. Meanwhile, the AUD may also struggle following the recent reassessment of interest rate expectations after the recent Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) meeting in which interest rates were left unchanged.

UK markets will focus on the Quarterly Inflation Report from the Bank of England though the political situation may hold some interesting implications for GBP if polls continue to show that the gap between the governing Labour party and Conservative opposition continues to narrow. Prospects of a hung parliament will hardly hold any positive implications for GBP, a prospect which could limit any potential for GBP to recover ahead of May elections. The drop below 1.60 for Cable (GBP/USD) could extend further, especially as the BoE has kept the door open to further asset purchases if needed.

Posted in Australia, Bond markets, central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, Europe, Financial crisis, Fiscal/Budget, FX, Greece, Interest rates, Japan, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

A set back for the pound

June 18, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

The multi week rally in the pound (GBP) has hit a snag as the currency has failed to extend gains above its recent highs around 1.66 against the dollar (USD).  The surprising fall in UK retail sales, with sales dropping by 0.6% from April compared to expectations of a 0.3% increase, dealt GBP another blow.   Sales were down 1.6% from a year earlier.  This is bad news for those that had believed that the UK consumer was enduring the economic downturn with some resilience. 

The reality is that the recovery in the economy will be a bumpy ride.  Whilst there have been some signs of improvement in the economy it is by no means a broad based pattern.  I would warn at getting too carried away with recovery expectations.  There have been clear signs of strengthening in both manufacturing and service sector survey data but they still only point to a gradual recovery in the months ahead. 

Moreover, some UK housing market indicators have pointed to early signs of recovery but a lot of this is due to a lack of supply and at best the housing market is entering a period of stabilisation.   Despite the signs of economic stabilisation the British Chamber of Commerce (BCC) cut its forecasts for the UK economy to -3.8% this year compared to a previous forecast of -2.8%.  

Meanwhile, UK banks continue to restrain credit and may even need more equity capital on top of the $158 billion in capital already raised according to Bank of England governor Mervyn King in his Mansion House speech.  He also warned about a “protracted” economic recovery. The good news is that the BoE is in no rush to take back its aggressive monetary easing and £125 billion asset purchase plan, but unless banks pass the benefits of this onto borrowers the fledgling recovery could stall quite quickly.   

The desire not to act quickly to reverse monetary policy was echoed in the minutes of the June BoE meeting, which revealed a unanimous 9-0 vote to maintain the status quo on policy.  The minutes also noted that the near term risks to the economy had lessened but monetary policy committee members remained cautious about the medium term prospects.  It is likely that the BoE will take several more months to gauge how successful policy has been. 

All of this highlights that GBP will be vulnerable to periodic bouts of profit taking and reversal.  Its ascent from its lows against the USD below 1.40 has been dramatic and rapid.  I believe that much of its gain has been justified especially as it had fallen to extreme levels of undervaluation.  Moreover, aggressive policy actions, both on fiscal and monetary policy, suggest that UK economic recovery will come quicker than Europe. This implies that GBP will at the least continue to recover against the euro (EUR) despite the weak retail sales induced set back.   

I also look for GBP to extend gains against the USD over coming months, with GBP/USD likely to end the year in the 1.70-1.80 region rather than low 1.60s where it is now. Market positioning leaves plenty of scope for GBP short covering over coming weeks adding further potential for recovery.  GBP appreciation will not continue in a straight line however, but set backs going forward should be looked upon as providing opportunities to rebuild long positions.

Posted in bank rescue, central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, Europe, Financial crisis, Monetary Policy, UK. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

What the G8 communiqué didn’t say

June 15, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

There was a stark contrast between the outcome of the weekend’s G8 meeting in Lecce, Italy, and April’s G20 summit in London.  For a start, the tone was far more positive than in London, with Finance Minsters attending the meeting indicating that economic forecasts may need to be revised upwards rather than the steady stream of downward revisions seen over recent months.

The overall tone was one of cautious optimism.  The communiqué noted “there are signs of stabilization in our economies, including a recovery of stock markets, a decline in interest rate spreads, improved business and consumer confidence”.  However, at the behest of the UK the comments “but the situation remains uncertain and significant risks remain to economic and financial stability” was inserted into the final communiqué.   Such an inclusion is logical and at least suggests that officials are not getting to carried away with the improvement in recent data. 

Officials also began discussing “exit strategies” in terms of withdrawing massive global monetary and fiscal stimulus and even requested the IMF look at the issue in more detail.  Whilst it is premature to even discuss exit strategies the comments were clearly aimed at easing bond market concerns about widening fiscal deficits and inflation risks.  As Tim Geithner highlighted, recovery would be stronger if “if we make clear today how we get back to fiscal sustainability when the storm has fully passed”.   Nonetheless, a mere discussion about exit strategy is highly unlikely to remove the current angst that has built up in bond markets globally. 

Additionally, the communiqué included a commitment to develop standards governing the conduct of international business and finance, international regulatory reform, exchange of information for tax purposes and a commitment to refrain from protectionism.   None of these points will move markets this week and all were unsurprising discussion points. 

So what was missing?  The issue of stress tests on European banks was left out of the final communiqué even though it was discussed at the meeting. Reported disagreements with Germany and France over transparency over the publication of stress test results meant that an agreement could not be reached.  This is a big disappointment.  I have written about the issue in two previous posts “European economy in a whole lot of trouble” and “Stress testing European and UK banks” on my blog Econometer.   The fact that more wasn’t done will mean that uncertainty about the health of balance sheets in particular of banks in Germany will remain a constraint to European recovery.  At the least it will make it increasingly likely that in addition to a sharp decline in European growth this year GDP could also drop in 2010.

In addition, economic data continues to lag in the Eurozone compared to the improving signs in the US and elsewhere as highlighted by the huge 21% annual drop in April Eurozone industrial production at the end of last week.  This data even led to another omission with reference to “encouraging figures in the manufacturing sector” previously included in the draft dropped in the final communiqué.   It is clearly too early to talk about manufacturing recovery.

Also missing in the final communiqué was any reference to currencies. Although it was always unlikely that FX would be a major topic at the meeting due to the absence of central bankers attending, the drop in the dollar and concerns from foreign official investors (see a recent post on my blog “Are foreign investors really turning away from US debt”) raised the prospect that there would be some international backing of the US “strong dollar” policy led by the US. 

In the event there wasn’t any comment, but dollar positive comments on the sidelines of the meeting will likely limit any pressure on the dollar this week.  The dollar will be helped by comments on the sidelines of the G8 meeting as well as important comments from Russian Finance Minister Kudrin who stated that he has full confidence in the dollar with no immediate plans to move to a new reserve currency. Ahead of the meeting of BRIC countries this week the comments from Russia add further evidence that there will be no plan to move away from the dollar. Moreover, geopolitical tensions including the protests over the results of Iran’s elections as well as more jawboning from North Korea will work in favour of the dollar this week. 

The euro could look especially vulnerable this week. The lack of attention on European banks stress tests will be a disappointment for those hoping for more transparency and will act as a further drag on the euro.  This is likely to see the euro struggle to make much headway this week, with the recent high above 1.43 likely to provide tough resistance to any move higher in EUR/USD, with a bigger risk of a pull back towards the 1.37-1.38 levels.

Posted in bank rescue, Bond markets, central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, Europe, Financial crisis, Germany, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . 2 Comments »
« Older posts
Newer posts »