Risk On / Risk Off

October 16, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Risk was firmly back on over the past few days as the majority of earnings came in stronger than expected; around 80% of S&P 500 companies have beaten expectations so far. Data releases in the US have also continued to beat forecasts, the latest of which was the September industrial production report. The dollar stood little chance of a recovering against this background and continues to languish around 14-month lows.

Sterling has been the star performer, perhaps a reflection of the fact that the market was extremely short (CTFC IMM data revealed record net short sterling positions last week) and some hints that the Bank of England may not extend quantitative easing was sufficient to provoke a short covering rally. Still the pound’s gains may prove short-lived until there are clearer signs of economic recovery and of a turn in the interest rate cycle.

There will be some key events and data over the coming week that will give further direction to sterling including a speech by BoE Governor King, MPC minutes, retail sales and preliminary Q3 GDP data. Overall, the data are unlikely to deliver much of a boost to the pound even though both retail sales and GDP are likely to deliver positive readings. Sentiment for the pound continues to swing in a wide range and though a lot of negativity was in the price a sustained recovery is far off. The risks remain that GBP/USD will push back towards support around 1.5902.

I still believe that there is little positive to be said for the euro too. The currency benefits from a weaker dollar but is hardly supported by fundamentals especially as a stronger euro damages one of the main engines of eurozone growth, namely exports. EUR/USD will struggle to make headway through 1.50 though once through here it could easily be carried higher. The most positive factor supporting the euro is the continued recycling of central bank intervention flows here in Asia and this may be sufficient to propel EUR/USD through 1.50 before hitting a wall of resistance around 1.5084.

The dollar itself may be given a lifeline from what looks like a softer tone to markets at the end of the week but overall sentiment remains very bearish despite attempts by various US officials to talk the dollar higher this week. The Fed’s Fisher hit the nail on the head when he said that the dollar’s long term value depends on policymakers “getting it right”. In the short term however, it’s all about risk and increasingly it will be about interest rate differentials, both of which will play negatively for the dollar.

Posted in Currencies, Economics, Economy, Europe, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

What to watch this week

October 12, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Over recent days trading has been characterised by dollar weakness, stronger equities, rising commodity prices and most recently an increase in US bond yields, the latter driven by some slightly hawkish Fed comments. Whether the tone of stronger attraction to risk trades continues will largely depend on US Q3 earnings however, with many earnings reports scheduled this week.

Given the plethora of Fed officials on the wires over recent days and the mixed comments from these officials there may more attention on US CPI on Thursday than usual but the data is unlikely to fuel any concern about inflation risks. Instead there will be more interest on the Fed FOMC minutes on Wednesday which will once again be scrutinised for the timing of an exit strategy.

Over the week there is plenty for markets to digest aside from earnings reports. US consumer and manufacturing reports will garner most attention. The key release is US September retail sales (Wed) where some payback for the “cash for clunkers” related surge in sales over the last month is likely to result in a drop in headline retail sales, though underlying sales will likely post a modest rise.

Fed speeches will also be monitored and speakers include Kohn, Dudley, Tarullo and Bullard this week. Recent comments have hinted that some Fed members are becoming increasingly concerned about the timing of policy reversal and further signs of this in this week’s speeches may give the dollar some comfort but this will prove limited given that the Fed is still a long way off from reversing policy.

Even if the market believes the Fed is starting to contemplate the timing of reversing its current policy setting it is unclear that the dollar will benefit much in the current environment. Sentiment remains bearish; speculative dollar sentiment deteriorated sharply over the past week according to the CFTC Commitment of Traders (IMM) data, to levels close to the lowest for the year.

Moreover, the correlation between interest rate differentials and currencies is still insignificant in most cases suggesting that even a jump in yields such as the move prompted by last week’s comments by Fed Chairman Bernanke should not automatically be expected to boost the dollar. Once markets become more aggressive in pricing in higher US interest rates this may change but there is little sign of this yet

In contrast the euro continues to benefit from recycling of central bank reserves and recorded a jump in speculative appetite close to its highest level this year according to the IMM data. Reserve flows from central banks may contribute to EUR/USD taking aim at its year high around 1.4844 (last tested on 24 September 09) over coming days.

Posted in central banks, Currencies, Economy, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

Is the Fed trying to support the dollar?

October 9, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Did Fed Chairman Bernanke really provide any real support to the dollar when he said at the Board of Governors conference on Thursday that the Fed will be prepared to tighten monetary policy when the outlook for the economy “has improved sufficiently”. Various newswires report that these comments have given the dollar some relief but the reality is that Bernanke only stated the obvious. Of course the Fed has to raise interest rates at some point and most likely this will be when the economic recovery looks sustainable. There is indication when this point in time will be, however.

In fact there was unsurprisingly no sign from Bernanke that the Fed was preparing to raise rates any time soon. As was noted in the September 23 Fed FOMC statement Bernanke reiterated that the Fed “believe that accommodative policies will likely be warranted for an extended period”. An extended period could mean at the least some months but even years and this is no exaggeration.

In 2001 the Fed did not begin to hike rates until around 2 ½ years after the end of the recession whilst in 1990-91 rates did not go up until close to 3 years after recession ended. Arguably this recession was worse in terms of depth and breadth suggesting that it will take a long time before the Fed even contemplates reversing policy. In any case the first step is to reduce the size of the Fed’s balance sheet.

Admittedly there has been some suggestions from other Fed members that when interest rates are raised it may be done “with greater force” as stated by Fed Governor Warsh recently but others such as NY Fed President Dudley have said that the pace of recovery “is not likely to be robust”, suggesting a more cautious tone and also highlighting that there is some debate within the Fed about the timing of exit strategies and raising interest rates.

There is no doubt that some Fed members are becoming more nervous about holding policy at such an accommodative level but it could still be several months before policy is reversed given the massive excess capacity in the product and labour markets and benign outlook for inflation. Judging by past history markets have little to be nervous about in terms of an early rate hike.

For the dollar this is bad news and as noted in my previous post the dollar will suffer from a growing yield disadvantage as other countries raise interest rates ahead of the Fed. The dollar may have benefited from some short covering at the end of the week and this could have been provoked by Bernanke’s comments but if so, the dollar’s gains are likely to be short-lived as investors take the opportunity of better levels to take short positions in the currency.

Posted in central banks, Currencies, Economics, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , . 3 Comments »

Where will interest rates go up next?

October 7, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Following the decision by the Reserve Bank of Australia to raise interest rates attention has swiftly turned to which central bank will move next. Indeed, there has been a reassessment of global interest rate decisions following Australia’s move. The hike in Australia is unlikely, however, to be quickly followed by the US, Japan, Europe or UK where policy is set to remain highly accommodative for long while.

Attention will however, turn to the Bank of Korea as well as the RBNZ and Norges Bank. In particular, the Norges Bank may be the next to hike when it meets on October 28. Norway has already appears to be priming markets for a rate hike. The RBNZ is likely to be slower to hike given the still slow pace of recovery in New Zealand and comfortable inflation backdrop.

The impact on currencies is not straightforward as the bigger influence on currency markets throughout the crisis has been risk appetite rather than interest rates. However, the influence of risk on currencies is beginning to wane and although interest rates have not been a major driver of currencies over recent months the move by the RBA likely accelerates the process of yield re-emerging as a key currency driver.

This is a big problem for the US dollar given that the Fed is unlikely to be quick to raise interest rates even if quantitative easing is withdrawn sooner. This means that the dollar will suffer from a growing yield disadvantage as interest rate hikes are priced in elsewhere. Taken together with improving risk appetite as reflected in the resilience of global equity markets, the main casualty will be the dollar, hit both from a yield and risk appetite perspective.

Risk currencies and those currencies with the greater prospect of higher rates will do well meaning further upside for the Australian dollar and New Zealand dollar as well as the Norwegian krone. Asian currencies look to continue to strengthen with the Korean won remaining an outperformer despite intervention threats by the Korean central bank. The euro will benefit from dollar weakness but is unlikely to benefit from anything euro specific given the likely slower pace of recovery in the eurozone. Meanwhile sterling is likely to remain under pressure, not helped by yield or risk appetite, and sentiment hit afresh by weak data.

Posted in Asia, central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, equity markets, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . 5 Comments »

Talking about currencies

October 5, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

It’s always the same story.  Ahead of the G7 (or G8 and now more important G20) meetings speculation of decisive action on currencies intensifies.  Traders and investors become cautious on the off chance that something significant will happen but the majority of times nothing of note emerges.

There was no difference this time around.  The G7 Finance Ministers meeting in Istanbul failed to deliver anything substantive on currencies, repeating the usual mantra about the adverse impact of “excess volatility and disorderly movements”.  Although the group pledged to monitor FX markets there was no indication of imminent action. 

The lack of action is perhaps surprising in one respect as there were plenty of central bankers and finance officials talking about currencies in the run up to the G7 meeting, most of which were attempting to talk the dollar higher against their respective currencies.  Given the increase in rhetoric ahead of the meeting, the relatively weak statement now leaves the door open to further dollar weakness.

The strongest indication of any FX action or intervention came from the country that was supposedly the least concerned about currency strength; Japanese Finance Minister Fujii warned that Japan “will take action” if “currencies show some excessive moves”.  The shift in stance from Japan since the new government took power has been stark (considering that the new government was supposedly in favour of a stronger yen).  Markets will likely continue to test the resolve of the Japanese authorities and buy yen anyway.

Although the G7 statement said little to support the dollar and the overall tone to the dollar likely remains negative over coming months, the softer tone to equity markets and run of weaker economic data in the US – the latest data to disappoint was the September US jobs report – may give some risk aversion related relief to the dollar this week. 

Weaker data and equities alongside the impact of official rhetoric is being reflected in CFTC Commitment of Traders’ data (a good gauge of speculative market positioning) which revealed a sharp drop in short dollar positions, by around a quarter, highlighting for a change, an improvement in dollar sentiment over the last week. 

The biggest losers in terms of speculative positioning were the British pound, where the net short position reached its most extreme since mid September 2008, and Canadian dollar where the net long position was cut by almost half.  Again this may reflect official views on currencies, with Canadian officials expressing concern about the strength of the Canadian dollar in contrast to the perception that UK officials favour a weaker pound.
Central bank meetings (BoE, ECB, RBA) will dominate the calendar this week and more comments on currencies are likely even if interest rates are left unchanged.  Meanwhile FX markets will continue to watch equities, and the start of the US Q3 earnings season will give important signals to determine the sustainability of the recent equity market rally.  Recent weak economic data has already cast doubt about a speedy recovery and if earnings disappoint risk aversion could once again be back on the table.

Posted in central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, equity markets, Europe, Japan, Monetary Policy, UK, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . 1 Comment »
« Older posts
Newer posts »