Fed keeps the risk trade party going

November 17, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Risk is back on and the liquidity taps are flowing. Fed Chairman Bernanke noted that it is “not obvious” that US asset prices are out of line with underlying values, comments that were echoed by Fed Vice Chairman Kohn, effectively giving the green light to a further run up in risk trades. The last thing the Fed wants to do is ruin a good party and the comments indicate that the surge in equities over recent months will not be hit by a reversal in monetary policy any time soon.  

Aside from comments by Fed officials risk appetite was also boosted by a stronger than forecast rise in US October retail sales, with US markets choosing to ignore the sharp downward revision to the previous month’s sales, the weaker than forecast ex-autos reading and a surprisingly large drop in the Empire manufacturing survey in November.

Fed comments were not just focussed on the economy and equity markets as Bernanke also tried to boost confidence in the beleaguered USD, highlighting that the Fed is “attentive” to developments in the currency.  He added that the Fed will help ensure that the USD is “strong and a source of global financial stability”.  The comments had a brief impact on the USD and may have given it some support but this is likely to prove short lived. 

The reality is that the Fed is probably quite comfortable with a weak USD given the positive impact on the economy and lack of associated inflation pressures and markets are unlikely to take the Fed’s USD comments too seriously unless there is a real threat of the US authorities doing something to arrest the decline in the USD, a threat which has an extremely low probability.

It is perhaps no coincidence that the Fed is attempting to talk up the USD at the same time that US President Obama meets with Chinese officials.  The comments pre-empt a likely push by China for the US not to implement policies that will undermine the value of the USD but comments by Obama appear to be fairly benign, with the President noting that the US welcomes China’s move to a “more market based currency over time”. The relatively soft tone of these comments will further dampen expectations of an imminent revaluation of the CNY.

Posted in Asia, central banks, China, Currencies, Economics, Economy, equity markets, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

Is China about to revalue the Yuan?

November 15, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Speculation has intensified that China will allow the CNY to resume appreciation. As well as a move in USD/CNY NDFs, implied options volatility has also risen. Speculation of CNY revaluation follows a significant change by China’s central bank, the PBOC to its stated FX policy in its quarterly monetary policy report last week.

The timing of the change in rhetoric should come as little surprise as it coincides with greater international calls for a stronger CNY to help rebalance the global economy as well as an improvement in economic data domestically. China has so far resisted such calls but the time may now be right for China to play its part in the global rebalancing process.

Recall that China had allowed a close to 20% appreciation of the CNY between July 2005 and July 2008 but re-pegged to the USD as the financial crisis intensified. This policy proved to be the correct one during the crisis as a stable versus appreciating exchange rate not only helped exports but helped contribute to China’s economic resilience during the crisis.

Now however, this policy is no longer needed. The worst of the crisis is over and China’s economy is doing remarkably well. Keeping the CNY artificially undervalued may stoke potential inflationary problems and distort the recovery process, whilst limiting the shift to a more consumer based economy. Managing China’s massive $2 trillion + of exchange reserves is becoming a more complicated and difficult process too. Moreover, the undervalued CNY is proving to be a global problem and hindering the adjustment of global imbalances.

Will there be an imminent revaluation of the CNY? China is in no rush to see the CNY appreciate and is unlikely to act when US President Obama is visiting. If anything, the Chinese authorities will renew the CNY appreciation trend when there is less political pressure as the last thing they want to do is to appear to be bowing to US or international pressure.

Yes the CNY is undervalued and the Chinese know this well. What is different this time is that the rest of Asia wants China to move and this is sufficient for China to act eventually but not imminently. The Chinese authorities are concerned about hot money flows and do not want to give the impression that they are embarking on an aggressive revaluation path. Gradual is the way to go but there is still room for markets to price in more appreciation next year.

What will happen during Obama’s visit is that the Chinese delegation will push for the US not to implement policies that will undermine the value of the USD especially in relation to the US fiscal deficit and the burgeoning Fed balance sheet. In return the US will push China into allowing the CNY to strengthen.

China appears to be in a stronger bargaining position given that China remains the biggest buyer of US Treasuries and the US will do little to jeopardise these investment flows. Perhaps China has pre-empted the US calls for a stronger CNY by changing the language in its monetary policy statement and it was likely no coincidence that the change happened just ahead of the US visit.

Posted in Asia, central banks, China, Currencies, Economics, emerging markets, FX, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , . 2 Comments »
Newer posts »