Addicted to the medicine

September 7, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

It comes as a relief to markets that G20 officials have agreed it is too early to begin withdrawing massive fiscal, monetary and financial support.   However, it is hardly surprising that officials are not formulating an early exit from emergency measures especially given the ongoing uncertainty about the pace and shape of global economic recovery.  

The latest US jobs report did not help clarify the outlook for markets as a smaller than forecast drop in employment in August (-216k) weighed against a surprise jump in the unemployment rate to a 26-year high of 9.7% and downward revisions to past months employment data.

There is a growing possibility that the Fed’s expectation the unemployment rate will breach 10% by the end of the year looks may be hit even earlier.  Fears about a “jobless recovery” will likely increase as a lack of hiring is set to persist for some time yet. 

The absence of any near term reversal of stimulus measures reduces the risk of a “double dip” recession but at some point there has to be a reckoning. Fiscal positions have blown out for many countries and will eventually require spending cuts, higher taxes and/or privatisation in addition to likely increases in the retirement ages for workers, to rectify them. It is questionable how sustainable recovery will be once such measures begin to be implemented.

In the meantime, it is not even evident that policy is working efficiently. Arguably yields on bonds and corporate debt are lower than they would otherwise have been had it not been for central bank actions but lenders are still not passing the additional liquidity to consumers and households against the background of fears about a rising tide of bad loans and delinquencies.

I would compare this to a patient who came close to death and has finally come off life support as the worst passed but has relied on support in the form of various strong medicines to keep him (or her) going.  The risk that the patient has become overly dependent on the drugs has grown but it is highly unclear how he will fare once he is weaned off.  

Fears about the ability of the patient to stand on his own two feet will increase.  The risk that the patient will relapse is intensifying but his ability to pay for more medicine is already diminishing and his options are running out quickly.

Posted in Bond markets, central banks, Economics, Economy, Financial crisis, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , . 1 Comment »

Speculative dollar sentiment worsens

September 2, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Data releases continue to fail to inspire markets despite the continuing run of better than expected numbers. In the US the Chicago PMI reached the critical boom/bust level of 50.0 in August whilst the less closely followed Milwaukee PMI surged into expansion territory at 56.0.  This revealed some upside risk to the ISM manufacturing index which duly beat consensus coming at 52.9 in August.  The fact that positive data is failing to lift markets is a sign of fatigue and stock markets appear to be running out of fuel.

From an FX perspective these developments will not be sufficient to provoke a break out of well worn ranges. Risk trades remain in favour but the momentum is limited. The prognosis does not look as positive for the dollar as the generally improving environment for risk will play negatively. Speculative sentiment (CFTC Commitment of Traders IMM data) has indeed worsened for the dollar; IMM data revealed net dollar short positions increasing sharply in the latest week, with market positioning worse than the 3-month average.

Much will depend on the US jobs report on Friday but until then the dollar is likely to cling to the weaker end of ranges. I believe that the dollar index will avoid dropping below its August 5th low of 77.428. The main exception to dollar weakness appears to be sterling where sentiment has become more bearish recently. This was reflected in the IMM report in which aside from the dollar, the pound has also been a loser and the only other currency for which speculative appetite worsened.

Posted in Currencies, Economics, Economy, equity markets, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

An unusual dollar reaction

August 8, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Although many market participants are on summer holidays this has not prevented some interesting market moves in the wake of yet more improvement in economic data and earnings.  The most noteworthy release was the July US jobs report which revealed a better than forecast 247,000 job losses and a surprise decline in the unemployment rate to 9.4%.  Moreover, past revisions added 43,000 to the tally.

Although it is difficult to get too optimistic given that job losses since December 2007 have totalled 6.7 million, the biggest drop since WW2, the direction is clearly one of improvement.  Nonetheless, markets were given a dose of reality by the drop in US consumer credit in June, which gives further reason to doubt the ability of the US consumer to contribute significantly to recovery.

The data spurred a further rally in stocks and a sell of in Treasuries.   Such a reaction was unsurprising but the more intriguing move was seen in the US dollar, which after some initial slippage managed a broad based appreciation in contrast to the usual sell off in the wake of better data and improved risk appetite.

It is too early to draw conclusions but the dollar reaction suggests that yield considerations are perhaps beginning to show renewed signs of influencing currencies following a long period where the FX/interest rate relationship was practically non-existent.  Indeed, the strengthening in the dollar corresponded with a hawkish move in interest rate futures as the market probability of a rate hike by the beginning of next year increased.

Since the crisis began the biggest driver of currencies has been risk aversion, a factor that relegated most other influences including the historically strong driver, interest rate differentials, to the background.  More specifically, much of the strengthening in the dollar during the crisis was driven by US investor repatriation from foreign asset markets as deleveraging intensified.   This repatriation far outweighed foreign selling of US assets and in turn boosted the dollar.

Over the past few months this reversed as risk appetite improved and the pace of deleveraging lessened.  Ultra easy US monetary policy also put the dollar in the unfamiliar position of becoming a funding currencies for higher yielding assets and currencies though admittedly this was all relative as yields globally dropped.   The dollar also suffered from concerns about its role as a reserve currency but failed to weaken dramatically as much of the concern expressed by central banks was mere rhetoric.

Where does this leave the dollar now?  Risk will remain a key driver of the dollar but already its influence is waning as reflected in the fact that the dollar has remained range bound over recent weeks despite an improvement in risk appetite.   As for interest rates their influence is set to grow as markets price in rate hikes and as in the past, more aggressive expectations of relative interest rate hikes will play the most positive for the respective currency.

It is still premature for interest rates to overtake risk as the principal FX driver.   Even if rates increase in importance I still believe interest rate markets are overly hawkish in the timing of rate hikes. A reversal in tightening expectations could yet push the dollar lower.  This is highly possible given the benign inflationary environment and massive excess capacity in the US economy.

Eventually the dollar will benefit from the shift in interest rate expectations as markets look for the Fed to be more aggressive than other central banks in reversing policy but this could take some time. Until then the dollar is a long way from a real recovery and will remain vulnerable for several months to come as risk appetite improves further.

Posted in central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, Financial crisis, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . 1 Comment »

Recovery hopes spoiled by the consumer

July 31, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

News that US Q2 GDP dropped by less than expected, with the 1% fall in GDP over the quarter far smaller than the annualised 6.4% drop in the previous quarter, adds to the plethora of evidence highlighting that the US recession is coming closer to ending.  The bad news, albeit backward looking was revealed in the downward revisions to growth in the previous quarters, which indicated that the recession has been more severe than previously thought.  

Within the Q2 GDP data the details revealed that consumer spending weakened by far more than expected. The recession is also breaking all sorts of records as the annual 3.9% decline in growth was the biggest since WWII and the fourth quarterly decline in a row was the longest on record. Nonetheless, inventories look a lot leaner following their sharp drop over the quarter and the deterioration in business investment appears to be slowing.  The data also showed that the Fed´s preferred gauge of inflation (core PCE deflator) remained relatively well behaved.

The downward revisions to past data and the fact that growth was boosted in Q2 by government spending as well as very weak consumer spending will takes some of the shine off the less than forecast drop in GDP.  Nonetheless, the data is still backward looking.  The evidence of recovery highlighted in recent housing data as well as some bottoming out in manufacturing conditions, taken together with less severe readings in jobs data  are difficult to ignore.  This was echoed in the Fed´s Beige Book which revealed that economic deterioration was becoming less marked.

The most worrying aspect of the report and something that cannot be downplayed however, is consumer spending. Massive wealth loss, rising unemployment, tight credit conditions, reduced income and consumer deleveraging all point to a very subdued outlook for the US consumer in the months ahead and only a gradual pace of economic recovery. The US savings rate is set to move higher even from its current 15 year high and spending on big ticket items will remain fragile at best.   Although the upcoming US jobs report will likely show a less severe pace of Job losses in July, the drop in payrolls will still remain significant and hardly  conducive of a turnaround in spending. 

Although some policy makers have indicated that policy should not be kept too loose for too long the weak consumer outlook suggests that inflation is likely to remain subdued for a long time to come.  So whilst it is easy to get excited about the signs of recovery increasingly being revealed in economic data this should not be taken as a cue to reverse policy. The recovery process remains a “long, hard, slog” and the massive excess capacity in the global economy, especially  in developed countries suggests that interest rates will remain at ultra low levels for many months.

Some clues to central bank thinking will be seen over coming days as interest rate decisions in Australia, UK, and Eurozone move into focus. Although none of the Banks are expected to tighten policy it will be interesting to see whether the rhetoric becomes more hawkish. The RBA in particular will likely indicate that the room for further rate cuts has diminished. In Europe, following the very soft inflation data in July the ECB will be comfortable in its current policy settings.  In the UK attention will focus on the BoE´s asset purchase programme and the possibility of increasing purchases from the current GBP 125 billion, especially after the MPC surprisingly did not increase purchases at its last meeting.

Posted in central banks, Economics, Economy, Europe, Financial crisis, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, UK, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . 1 Comment »

Watch out for the pitfalls in H2 2009

July 6, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Equity and credit markets have begun the second half of 2009 looking quite fatigued, which is not a good sign ahead of the Q2 earning season.   Perhaps the fact that markets have come so far in such a short period of time has itself prompted a pause. An alternative explanation is that the summer lull is kicking in, with many investors taking the end of H1 2009 as an excuse to book profits and wait until activity picks up again post summer holidays.  A more worrying and more likely explanation is that the massive improvement in market sentiment seen in H1 2009 is  giving way to uncertainty.

Relief that there will be no collapse of the global financial system is not sufficient to keep the momentum in equity and credit markets going into the second half of the year. Until now there has been plenty of less negative news and use of the now worn phrase “green shoots”, but little information to judge the magnitude and speed of recovery going forward.

There are plenty of factors that will dampen recovery in the months ahead. Higher unemployment, massive wealth loss and increased savings will provide a clear downdraft to the global economy. Banks will be increasingly laden with bad loans due to credit card delinquencies, commercial real estate defaults and other sour loans and are unlikely to step up lending in a hurry. In addition, it is still unclear how quickly toxic debt will be removed from banks’ balance sheets, which will act as another impediment to recovery.

Risks outside the US remain significant. Although the outlook for China is improving it is unclear whether the momentum of growth in the country will continue once current stimulus measures are utilised. Much will also depend on whether China and other export economies can shift growth impetus from external demand to domestic demand.

Moreover, concerns about the dollar’s use as a reserve currency continue to intensify as various large reserve holders attempt to diversify away from the dollar.  Although a dollar collapse is unlikely the risk that foreign investors reduce their exposure to US Treasuries remains a threat to the dollar.   This could push up long term interest rates and in turn mortgage rates in the US.  

The European economy is a particular riskto global recovery, with only a gradual recovery expected.  In particular, the biggest Eurozone economy Germany is struggling in the wake of a collapse in exports and a lack of domestic demand. Moreover, banking sector issues remain unresolved especially as there has been little information on European bank stress tests. The relative strength of the euro and inability of some countries in the Eurozone to devalue their way out of the downturn will also dampen recovery prospects.   These factors suggest that Europe will lag the recovery in other countries such as the US and UK where the policy response has arguably been more aggressive.  

The jobs market will lag the recovery process but there are signs that things are becoming less severe.  The pace of job losses in many countries is lessening.   In the US for example, non farm payrolls report revealed that average monthly job losses in the second quarter of 2009 at 436k were much lower than the 691k average monthly job losses in the first quarter.  The bad news however, is that unemployment rates continue to rise.  In the US the unemployment rate is likely to head to around 10% from 9.5% currently and this will be echoed in Europe where the unemployment is at a 10-year high of 9.5% currently. 

The bottom line is that the market rally may have been justified so far but there is little to carry the momentum forward. Equity valuations dropped to low levels in March but can be hardly considered cheap at present. The improvements in indicators of market stress have also reached dramatic levels and going forward there will be plenty of pitfalls in the months ahead.

Posted in bank rescue, central banks, China, Currencies, Economics. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . 3 Comments »
« Older posts
Newer posts »