Two-way FX risk returns

August 18, 2010 — Mitul Kotecha

It appears that there is a bit of a sea change taking place in currency markets. Since early June the trend in currency markets would have looked like a one way bet to most casual observers. For instance, the USD index was declining fairly steadily and predictability as US growth worries intensified and markets anticipated a resumption of quantitative easing by the Fed. This changed quite dramatically over recent days, with a significant degree of two-way risk re-entering the market as the USD shook off worries about Fed quantitative easing and instead rallied in the wake of higher risk aversion.

The introduction of two-way risk into the market will cause a rethink of the increasingly fashionable view that the USD was about to embark on a renewed negative trend. This change in market perspective has coincided with renewed concerns about European sovereign risks, even as European growth has come in much stronger than expected over Q2. Other currencies have also lost ground against the USD more recently, with the notable exception of the JPY which remains close to the psychological level of 85.00.

Until recently the move in FX markets since early June contrasted with my view that Q3 would be a period of uncertainty and volatility. Improved risk appetite reflected a decline in uncertainty but whilst I now believe that Q3 will see less of an increase in risk aversion than previously anticipated, my core views remain unchanged. I see the USD resuming an appreciation trend against the EUR and funding currencies (JPY and CHF) whilst weakening against higher yielding risk currencies (AUD, NZD and CAD) over the medium term.

Although FX markets will likely gyrate between the influences of risk aversion on the one hand and growth/interest rates on the other, risk is likely to take the upper hand over the coming weeks. The influence of risk aversion has jumped sharply over the last few weeks for almost all currencies. As risk appetite was improving as it has done for much of the period since early June, it played negatively for the USD but the recent increase in risk aversion – brought about by renewed growth concerns, sovereign worries in the eurozone, with Ireland in particular coming under scrutiny – has managed to reverse this trend. The one-way bet for investors now appears to be over.

Only time will tell if the EUR’s recent bull run has come to an end but there is sufficient evidence to suggest that plenty of good news has now been priced in and that further upside will be much more difficult to achieve. Even the recently strong growth data in the eurozone has thrown up potential problems including growing divergence as well as the potential for a slowdown over coming quarters. Further strengthening of the EUR will be a particular problem for eurozone growth, especially for exporting countries such as Germany. In any case, even the recent drop in the EUR leaves the currency at an overvalued level and susceptible to further falls. Over the coming weeks a period of consolidation is likely, with the EUR set to take a weaker tone.

The JPY in contrast has shown little sign of weakening and continues to flirt with the key psychological level of 85.00 much to the detriment of the Japanese economy, leading to growing frustration from Japanese officials. Much weaker than expected Q2 GDP data has given even more reason to engineer a weaker JPY but as yet the only intervention has come verbally and even this has not been particularly strong. In the absence of FX intervention, the Japanese authorities may be forced to consider other options such as increasing outright JGB purchases.

Like the EUR and JPY, GBP will find it tough to extend gains against the USD especially given that the doves at the Bank of England will likely remain in the ascendancy as growth moderates. GBP is also less undervalued than it was just a few weeks back suggesting that the argument for GBP strength has weakened. Nonetheless, GBP is likely to outperform against a generally weaker EUR ending 2010 around 0.78.

Similarly, CHF will likely maintain its strength against the EUR in the short term but unlike GBP this will likely give way to weakness and a gradual move higher in EUR/CHF to around 1.37 by year end. An eventual improvement in risk appetite and some relative economic underperformance will undermine the case for holding CHF.

Scandinavian currencies are likely to struggle in the short term due to market nervousness about a US double dip in an environment of elevated risk aversion. Interest rates will also play an important role in driving NOK and SEK as will be the case for most currencies eventually. Divergence in rate views for Norway and Sweden suggests holding a short SEK long NOK position. Overall, with two-way risk now much more evident as many investors return from their summer break the FX market will look far less predictable than it did before they left.

Posted in Australia, Bond markets, central banks, Commodities, Currencies, Economics, Economy, equity markets, Europe, eurozone, Federal Reserve, Financial crisis, Fiscal/Budget, FX, Germany, Interest rates, Japan, Monetary Policy, Politics, UK, US, US administration. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

What Stress?

July 22, 2010 — Mitul Kotecha

Fed Chairman Bernanke has inadvertently fuelled an increase in risk aversion in the wake of his testimony to the Senate. Although Bernanke noted that he did not see the prospects of a double-dip as a high probability event he stated that the economic outlook is “unusually uncertain”. Nonetheless, although such measures would be implemented if the situation deteriorated further, the Fed was not planning on extending its non-traditional policy options in the near term.
USD benefits as Bernanke does not indicate more quantitative easing.

A combination of caution about growth prospects and disappointment that Bernanke stopped short of indicating that the Fed would embark on further non-conventional policy measures left equities weaker, but the USD was stronger, both due to higher risk aversion as well as less risk of the Fed turning the USD printing press back on again. Bernanke is back at Congress today, with a speech to the House Panel. Although this is effectively a repeat of yesterday’s testimony, the Q&A session may throw up additional clues to Fed thinking and potential for extending quantitative easing but I suspect the USD will retain its firmer tone.

In Europe, most attention remains on the upcoming release of EU bank stress test results. Leaks suggest most banks will likely pass the EU bank stress tests, with the notable exceptions of a few Spanish Cajas and German Landesbanks. Already governments in Germany, France, Greece and Belgium have said their banks are likely to pass. We should all be bracing ourselves for relief to flow through European financial markets, but somehow this does not feel like an environment that will welcome such a result. More likely questions will be asked about why did so few banks fail and why the tests were not rigorous enough?

For example, the test for “sovereign shock” is said to affect only the value of government bonds that banks mark to market, but what about the far larger proportion of government debt that is held in banking books? There are also question marks over the capital hurdle, with the most adverse scenario that banks need to reach a maximum Tier 1 capital ratio of at least 6% by end 2011. Moreover, there have also been reported divisions within European Union (EU) members about how much information to divulge. EUR has also ready lost ground over recent days but the currency could face much more selling pressure into next week if the tests are found to lack credibility.

Please note that econometer.org will take a break until the week of 16th August. Good Luck.

Posted in bank rescue, Currencies, Economics, Economy, equity markets, Europe, eurozone, Federal Reserve, Fiscal/Budget, FX, Germany, Greece, Spain, US, US administration. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

EUR strength is overdone

July 19, 2010 — Mitul Kotecha

The latest in a long line of disappointing US data was released on Friday. University of Michigan consumer confidence sent an alarming signal about the propensity of the US consumer to contribute to economic recovery. Confidence dropped much more than expected, to its lowest level since August 2009, fuelling yet more angst about a double-dip in growth.

The Fed’s relatively dovish FOMC minutes last week contributed to the malaise and undermined the USD in the process as attention switched from the timing of exit strategies to whether the Fed will expand quantitative easing. Friday’s benign June CPI report left no doubt that the Fed has plenty of room on its hands, with core inflation remaining below 1% and likely to decelerate further over the coming months. Against this background Fed Chairman Bernanke’s semi-annual testimony to the US Congress (Wed/Thu) will be a particular focus, especially if he hints at potential for further QE, a possibility that appears remote, but could harm the USD.

Arguably the biggest event of the week is the European bank stress test results on Friday. Although several European governments have suggested that the banks in their countries will pass the tests there is still a considerable event risk surrounding the announcement. 91 banks are being tested and much will depend on how rigorous the tests are perceived to be. Should they be seen not to be sufficiently thorough, for instance in determining a realistic haircut on sovereign debt holdings, the potential for pressure on the EUR to increase once again will be high. Similarly debt auctions across Europe this week will also garner interest but similar success to last week’s Spanish auction cannot be guaranteed.

The big question in FX markets is whether the EUR can hold onto its recent gains and whether the USD will be punished further amidst growing double-dip worries. Interestingly the USD’s reaction on Friday to the soft consumer confidence data was not as negative as has been the case recently, with higher risk aversion once again outweighing negative cyclical influences. Various risk currencies actually came under pressure against the USD and this is likely to extend into this week. Despite a threat to the USD from any QE hints by Bernanke, speculative positioning has turned net short USD once again suggesting potential for less USD selling.

The bigger risk this week is to the EUR, which could face pressure on any disappointment from the bank stress test results. The EUR was strong against most major currencies last week, suggesting that the strengthening in EUR/USD is less to do with USD weakness, but more related to EUR strength. This strength in the EUR is hard to tally with the worsening economic outlook in the eurozone and the fact that a stronger EUR from an already overvalued level will crimp eurozone growth further. The latest CFTC IMM data has revealed a further covering of short positions, but this is likely to be close to running its course. Technically EUR/USD has broken above its ‘thick’ Ichimoku cloud, and the weekly MACD is turning above its signal line from oversold levels suggesting a period of further strength but its gains are set to be short-lived.

Posted in bank rescue, Bond markets, central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, equity markets, Europe, eurozone, Federal Reserve, Fiscal/Budget, FX, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, Politics, Spain, US, US administration. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

The Ball Is In the EU’s Court

March 4, 2010 — Mitul Kotecha

A run of data and events have continued this week’s theme of improving risk appetite. Greece lived up to expectations, with the government announcing a EUR 4.8 billion package of austerity measures amounting to around 2% of GDP. The US ADP jobs data was in line with expectations, with employment dropping by 20k in February, whilst ISM non-manufacturing index delivered an upside surprise to 53.0 in February, contrasting with a weaker eurozone Purchasing Managers Index (PMI).

Greece now believes it has lived up to its part of the bargain and the ball is now in the court of EU countries. However the issue of aid from the EU remains highly sensitive with little sign of any aid forthcoming from EU partners. Moreover, Germany dealt a blow to Greek hopes by stating that financial aid would not be discussed when the Greek Prime Minister visits tomorrow. Failure to provide such assistance could see Greece turn to the IMF. The key test will be the roll over of around EUR 22 billion of debt in April/May.

Markets have reacted positively to recent events, with Greek debt rallying and the EUR strengthening to a high of 1.3727 overnight amidst reports that regulators are investigating hedge fund trades shorting the EUR. The 17 February high of 1.3789 will provide strong resistance to further EUR/USD upside but the currency looks vulnerable to selling on rallies above its 20-day moving average around 1.3631. The EUR will be driven by news about any aid to Greece rather than data whilst the medium term outlook remains bearish.

In the US the steady but gradual recovery in the economy is continuing to take shape. The Fed’s Beige Book revealed that economic activity “continued to expand” but severe snowstorms restrained activity in several districts. Overall, the report revealed little new information following so soon after Fed Chairman Bernanke’s testimony. Today’s US releases are second tier, with a likely upward revision to Q4 non-farm productivity to around 6.5% and a 1.5% increase in January factory orders.

As has been the case recently the weekly jobless claims data will garner more attention than usual given that it has recently signaled deterioration in job conditions. One factor that could have distorted the claims as well as the payrolls data is harsh weather conditions in parts of the US. Indeed, this has led us to cuts in forecasts for February non-farm payrolls scheduled to be released tomorrow, with the real consensus likely to be much weaker than the -65k shown in the Bloomberg survey.

There are four central bank decisions of interest today no change is likely from all of them. Indonesia and Malaysia are both edging towards raising interest rates but are likely to wait until Q2 2010 before hiking. There will be no surprises if the Bank of England (BoE) and European Central Bank (ECB) leave policy unchanged too, but there will be particular interest in the ECB’s announcement on changes in liquidity provision and the BoE’s signals on the potential for further expansion in quantitative easing. A dovish signal from the BoE will deliver GBP a blow, leaving GBP/USD vulnerable to a drop back below 1.50.

Posted in central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, Europe, Federal Reserve, Financial crisis, Fiscal/Budget, FX, Germany, Greece, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, UK, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

Central banks in the spotlight

February 1, 2010 — Mitul Kotecha

The market mood continues to be weighed down by a combination of worries including monetary tightening in China and Greece’s debt woes. Consequently, risk aversion has taken a turn for the worse over the last couple of weeks. Measures of currency and equity market volatility have also spiked. Meanwhile, risk currencies have remained under pressure, especially those that are most sensitive to risk aversion including AUD, NZD, CAD, and a long list of emerging market currencies.

Greece’s problems remain a major drag on the EUR, with speculative sentiment for the currency dropping close to the all time low recorded in September 2008, according to the CFTC IMM data. Further developments including news that the European Commission will officially recommend that Greece should implement more severe cuts on public sector spending are unlikely to help to reverse negative sentiment for the currency. A lack of confidence and scepticism over Greece’s ability to cut its budget deficit suggest little respite for the EUR in the weeks ahead.

Markets will have plenty of other things to focus on this week, with various manufacturing and service sector PMIs, four major central bank decisions, and the January US non-farm payrolls report, due for release. The PMIs are likely to confirm that output in both manufacturing and service industries remains expansionary but only consistent with limited growth rather than the rapid rebound in activity seen following past recessions.

The most interesting central bank decision this week is likely to be that of the Reserve Bank of Australia. Recent data has if anything given more reason for the central bank to raise interest rates, including the latest release which was the TD Securities inflation gauge, which jumped 0.8% in January, the biggest increase in 6-months. Although a hike is now largely discounted, some hawkish rhetoric from the RBA could be sufficient to give the AUD some support.

Although the UK Bank of England is unlikely to shift policy at its meeting on Thursday the statement will be scrutinized for clues as to whether quantitative easing is over. Any indication that there will be no further QE measures will play positively for GBP given that it has been restrained by speculation that the BoE will increase asset purchases. No change is also expected by the ECB but once again Greece will likely dominate the press conference. Meanwhile Norway’s Norges Bank is likely to pause in its policy of gradual tightening.

Clearly the funding currency of choice, the USD, has been one of the main beneficiaries of higher risk aversion and this has been reflected in the latest CFTC Commitment of Traders report, which shows that net short aggregate USD speculative positions have dropped sharply, with USD positioning close to flat again. Similarly, the other beneficiary, namely the JPY, has also seen a significant shift in positioning as shorts have been covered. Expect more to come.

Appetite for carry trades was not be helped by the news that the UK’s Lord Turner has signalled a regulatory crackdown on FX carry trades. The report in the UK press fuelled a sell of in JPY crosses but is unlikely to have more than a short term market impact given the practical difficulties in regulating carry trades. Nonetheless, the fact that speculative positioning is still quite long in the AUD, NZD and CAD suggest scope for more downside in such currencies in the current risk averse environment.

Posted in Asia, Australia, central banks, China, Currencies, Economics, Economy, emerging markets, Europe, Financial crisis, Fiscal/Budget, FX, Greece, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »
« Older posts
Newer posts »