Talking about currencies

It’s always the same story.  Ahead of the G7 (or G8 and now more important G20) meetings speculation of decisive action on currencies intensifies.  Traders and investors become cautious on the off chance that something significant will happen but the majority of times nothing of note emerges.

There was no difference this time around.  The G7 Finance Ministers meeting in Istanbul failed to deliver anything substantive on currencies, repeating the usual mantra about the adverse impact of “excess volatility and disorderly movements”.  Although the group pledged to monitor FX markets there was no indication of imminent action. 

The lack of action is perhaps surprising in one respect as there were plenty of central bankers and finance officials talking about currencies in the run up to the G7 meeting, most of which were attempting to talk the dollar higher against their respective currencies.  Given the increase in rhetoric ahead of the meeting, the relatively weak statement now leaves the door open to further dollar weakness.

The strongest indication of any FX action or intervention came from the country that was supposedly the least concerned about currency strength; Japanese Finance Minister Fujii warned that Japan “will take action” if “currencies show some excessive moves”.  The shift in stance from Japan since the new government took power has been stark (considering that the new government was supposedly in favour of a stronger yen).  Markets will likely continue to test the resolve of the Japanese authorities and buy yen anyway.

Although the G7 statement said little to support the dollar and the overall tone to the dollar likely remains negative over coming months, the softer tone to equity markets and run of weaker economic data in the US – the latest data to disappoint was the September US jobs report – may give some risk aversion related relief to the dollar this week. 

Weaker data and equities alongside the impact of official rhetoric is being reflected in CFTC Commitment of Traders’ data (a good gauge of speculative market positioning) which revealed a sharp drop in short dollar positions, by around a quarter, highlighting for a change, an improvement in dollar sentiment over the last week. 

The biggest losers in terms of speculative positioning were the British pound, where the net short position reached its most extreme since mid September 2008, and Canadian dollar where the net long position was cut by almost half.  Again this may reflect official views on currencies, with Canadian officials expressing concern about the strength of the Canadian dollar in contrast to the perception that UK officials favour a weaker pound.
Central bank meetings (BoE, ECB, RBA) will dominate the calendar this week and more comments on currencies are likely even if interest rates are left unchanged.  Meanwhile FX markets will continue to watch equities, and the start of the US Q3 earnings season will give important signals to determine the sustainability of the recent equity market rally.  Recent weak economic data has already cast doubt about a speedy recovery and if earnings disappoint risk aversion could once again be back on the table.

Recovery hopes spoiled by the consumer

News that US Q2 GDP dropped by less than expected, with the 1% fall in GDP over the quarter far smaller than the annualised 6.4% drop in the previous quarter, adds to the plethora of evidence highlighting that the US recession is coming closer to ending.  The bad news, albeit backward looking was revealed in the downward revisions to growth in the previous quarters, which indicated that the recession has been more severe than previously thought.  

Within the Q2 GDP data the details revealed that consumer spending weakened by far more than expected. The recession is also breaking all sorts of records as the annual 3.9% decline in growth was the biggest since WWII and the fourth quarterly decline in a row was the longest on record. Nonetheless, inventories look a lot leaner following their sharp drop over the quarter and the deterioration in business investment appears to be slowing.  The data also showed that the Fed´s preferred gauge of inflation (core PCE deflator) remained relatively well behaved.

The downward revisions to past data and the fact that growth was boosted in Q2 by government spending as well as very weak consumer spending will takes some of the shine off the less than forecast drop in GDP.  Nonetheless, the data is still backward looking.  The evidence of recovery highlighted in recent housing data as well as some bottoming out in manufacturing conditions, taken together with less severe readings in jobs data  are difficult to ignore.  This was echoed in the Fed´s Beige Book which revealed that economic deterioration was becoming less marked.

The most worrying aspect of the report and something that cannot be downplayed however, is consumer spending. Massive wealth loss, rising unemployment, tight credit conditions, reduced income and consumer deleveraging all point to a very subdued outlook for the US consumer in the months ahead and only a gradual pace of economic recovery. The US savings rate is set to move higher even from its current 15 year high and spending on big ticket items will remain fragile at best.   Although the upcoming US jobs report will likely show a less severe pace of Job losses in July, the drop in payrolls will still remain significant and hardly  conducive of a turnaround in spending. 

Although some policy makers have indicated that policy should not be kept too loose for too long the weak consumer outlook suggests that inflation is likely to remain subdued for a long time to come.  So whilst it is easy to get excited about the signs of recovery increasingly being revealed in economic data this should not be taken as a cue to reverse policy. The recovery process remains a “long, hard, slog” and the massive excess capacity in the global economy, especially  in developed countries suggests that interest rates will remain at ultra low levels for many months.

Some clues to central bank thinking will be seen over coming days as interest rate decisions in Australia, UK, and Eurozone move into focus. Although none of the Banks are expected to tighten policy it will be interesting to see whether the rhetoric becomes more hawkish. The RBA in particular will likely indicate that the room for further rate cuts has diminished. In Europe, following the very soft inflation data in July the ECB will be comfortable in its current policy settings.  In the UK attention will focus on the BoE´s asset purchase programme and the possibility of increasing purchases from the current GBP 125 billion, especially after the MPC surprisingly did not increase purchases at its last meeting.