What’s driving FX – Interest rates or risk?

December 13, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

The November US retail sales report has really set the cat amongst the pigeons. For so long we have become accustomed to judging the move in the USD based on daily gyrations in risk aversion. Well, that may all be about to change. There was an inkling that all did not look right following the release of the November jobs report which unsurprisingly helped to boost risk appetite but surprisingly boosted the USD too.

It was easy to dismiss the USD reaction to year end position adjustment, markets getting caught short USDs etc. What’s more the shift in interest rate expectations following the jobs report in which markets began to price in an earlier rate hike in the US was quickly reversed in the wake of Fed Chairman Bernanke’s speech highlighting risks to the economy and reiterating the Fed’s “extended period” stance.

However, it all has happened again following the release of the November retail sales data, which if you missed it, came in stronger than expected alongside a similarly better than forecast reading for December Michigan confidence. The USD reaction was to register a broad based rally as markets once again moved to believe that the “extended period” may not be so extended after all.

Interest rates will become increasingly important in driving currencies over the course of the next few months but if anyone thinks that the Fed will shift its stance at this week’s FOMC meeting, they are likely to be off the mark. No doubt the Fed will note the recent improvement in economic data but this is highly unlikely to result in a change in the overall stance towards policy.

Further improvements in US data this week including industrial production, housing starts, Philly Fed and Empire manufacturing may lead markets to doubt this but the Fed calls the shots and a potentially dovish statement may act to restrain the USD this week. Also, it’s probably not a good idea to rule out the influence of risk appetite on currencies just yet and with a generally positive slate of data expected, firmer risk appetite will similarly act as a cap on the USD this week.

Other than the US events there is plenty of other potentially market moving data to digest this week. More central banks meet this week including the Riksbank, Norges Bank and Bank of Japan. No change is expected from all three but whilst the Riksbank is set to maintain a dovish stance the Norges Bank meeting is a closer call. So soon after the emergency BoJ meeting, a shift in policy appears unlikely but the pressure to increase Rinban (outright JGB buying) operations could throw up some surprises for markets.

Europe also has its fair share of releases this week including the two biggest data for markets out of the eurozone, namely, the German ZEW and IFO surveys as well as the flash December PMI readings. The biggest risk is for the ZEW survey which could suffer proportionately more in the wake of recent sovereign concerns in the Eurozone. Sovereign names may still lurk to protect the downside on EUR/USD and if the USD finds it tougher going as noted above, the EUR may be able to claw back some of its recent losses.

Posted in central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, Europe, FX, Germany, Interest rates, Japan, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

Contrasting the ECB with the Fed

November 23, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Whether its year end book closing/profit taking and/or renewed doubts about the shape of recovery, asset markets have turned south recently.  Investor mood appears to be souring as risk aversion creeps back into the market psyche.  A string of disappointing US data releases over the last week including core retail sales, Empire manufacturing, industrial production, and housing starts, contributed to the reduced appetite for risk, resulting in a soft finish to the week for equity markets and a firmer USD.

Things are likely to take a turn for the better this week, however. Data will shed a little more light on the pace and magnitude of economic recovery and could result in some improvement in appetite for risk trades.  Despite an expected downward revision to US Q3 GDP, forward looking data on home sales, durable goods orders and personal income and spending as well as consumer confidence are likely to reveal increases.  In the Eurozone, data economic releases will paint a similar picture, including an expected increase in the closely watched barometer of business confidence, the German IFO survey. 

At the least economic data will remove some, but by no means all doubts about a relapse in the recovery process.  There is no doubting the veracity of the recovery in equity and commodity prices, despite doubts about its sustainability. Central banks may not react uniformly to this and the policy impact could vary significantly.  Already it appears that the ECB is moving more quickly towards an exit strategy compared to the Fed.  Although ECB President Trichet highlighted that the crisis is far from over at the end of last week, the Bank announced tougher standards for asset backed securities used as collateral, indicating that the need to provide emergency support to banks is much lower than it was. 

Clearly the ECB wants to avoid letting the market become over dependent on the central bank and will look to implement measures to this aim.  In contrast, the Fed is showing little sign of beginning this process and at least one member of the FOMC, namely St. Louis Fed President Bullard, was quoted over the weekend advocating that the Fed keep its MBS buying programme beyond its scheduled close in March. Evidence of the contrasting stance is also reflected in the fact that the Fed’s balance sheet is expanding once again whilst the ECB’s is contracting.  As a result of firmer data and comments by Bullard the USD is set to go into the week under renewed pressure, albeit within well defined ranges.

Posted in central banks, Currencies, Economics, Economy, Europe, FX, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

US rates “low for long”

November 19, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Risk appetite is failing to show much improvement this week and sharply weaker than forecast US housing data dampened sentiment further following other soft data over recent days including the Empire manufacturing survey, industrial production and retail sales less autos. The data will add to concerns about the pace and magnitude of growth in the months ahead.

A sub-par recovery and benign inflation outlook are the two main reasons why the Fed will not hike rates for a long while yet. This was echoed by St. Louis Fed President Bullard – a voting member of the FOMC – who gave a little more colour on the Fed’s “extended period” statement. He highlighted the probability that US interest rates will not be raised until the first half of 2012.

Bullard noted that following the past two recessions the Fed did not raise rates until two and half to three years after recession ended. This is accurate given that in 2001 the Fed did not begin to hike rates until around 2 ½ years after the end of the recession whilst in 1990-91 rates did not go up until close to 3 years after recession ended. This recession just passed was arguably worse than both of the past two, so why should rates rise any earlier?

One factor that could trigger an earlier rate hike is the risks from the massive global liquidity fuelled carry trade fuelled by Fed policy. Bullard highlighted that the risks of creating an asset bubble from keeping rates “too low for too long” may prompt an earlier tightening. What will be important is that the Fed gets the exit strategy right and the risk that delaying any reduction in the Fed’s balance sheet and asset purchases could turn out to be inflationary which in turn would be negative for the USD and hit confidence in US assets.

The Fed is very likely to adjust the level of quantitative easing well before contemplating raising interest rates. The market is pricing in around 50bps of rate hikes in the next 12 months but even this looks to aggressive and as has been the case of recent months the market is likely to push back the timing of expected rate hikes. The consequences for the USD are negative at least until the market becomes more aggressive in pricing in US interest rate hikes or believes the Fed is serious about its exit strategy.

Posted in central banks, Currencies, Economics, FX, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

Fed keeps the risk trade party going

November 17, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Risk is back on and the liquidity taps are flowing. Fed Chairman Bernanke noted that it is “not obvious” that US asset prices are out of line with underlying values, comments that were echoed by Fed Vice Chairman Kohn, effectively giving the green light to a further run up in risk trades. The last thing the Fed wants to do is ruin a good party and the comments indicate that the surge in equities over recent months will not be hit by a reversal in monetary policy any time soon.  

Aside from comments by Fed officials risk appetite was also boosted by a stronger than forecast rise in US October retail sales, with US markets choosing to ignore the sharp downward revision to the previous month’s sales, the weaker than forecast ex-autos reading and a surprisingly large drop in the Empire manufacturing survey in November.

Fed comments were not just focussed on the economy and equity markets as Bernanke also tried to boost confidence in the beleaguered USD, highlighting that the Fed is “attentive” to developments in the currency.  He added that the Fed will help ensure that the USD is “strong and a source of global financial stability”.  The comments had a brief impact on the USD and may have given it some support but this is likely to prove short lived. 

The reality is that the Fed is probably quite comfortable with a weak USD given the positive impact on the economy and lack of associated inflation pressures and markets are unlikely to take the Fed’s USD comments too seriously unless there is a real threat of the US authorities doing something to arrest the decline in the USD, a threat which has an extremely low probability.

It is perhaps no coincidence that the Fed is attempting to talk up the USD at the same time that US President Obama meets with Chinese officials.  The comments pre-empt a likely push by China for the US not to implement policies that will undermine the value of the USD but comments by Obama appear to be fairly benign, with the President noting that the US welcomes China’s move to a “more market based currency over time”. The relatively soft tone of these comments will further dampen expectations of an imminent revaluation of the CNY.

Posted in Asia, central banks, China, Currencies, Economics, Economy, equity markets, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »

What to watch this week

October 12, 2009 — Mitul Kotecha

Over recent days trading has been characterised by dollar weakness, stronger equities, rising commodity prices and most recently an increase in US bond yields, the latter driven by some slightly hawkish Fed comments. Whether the tone of stronger attraction to risk trades continues will largely depend on US Q3 earnings however, with many earnings reports scheduled this week.

Given the plethora of Fed officials on the wires over recent days and the mixed comments from these officials there may more attention on US CPI on Thursday than usual but the data is unlikely to fuel any concern about inflation risks. Instead there will be more interest on the Fed FOMC minutes on Wednesday which will once again be scrutinised for the timing of an exit strategy.

Over the week there is plenty for markets to digest aside from earnings reports. US consumer and manufacturing reports will garner most attention. The key release is US September retail sales (Wed) where some payback for the “cash for clunkers” related surge in sales over the last month is likely to result in a drop in headline retail sales, though underlying sales will likely post a modest rise.

Fed speeches will also be monitored and speakers include Kohn, Dudley, Tarullo and Bullard this week. Recent comments have hinted that some Fed members are becoming increasingly concerned about the timing of policy reversal and further signs of this in this week’s speeches may give the dollar some comfort but this will prove limited given that the Fed is still a long way off from reversing policy.

Even if the market believes the Fed is starting to contemplate the timing of reversing its current policy setting it is unclear that the dollar will benefit much in the current environment. Sentiment remains bearish; speculative dollar sentiment deteriorated sharply over the past week according to the CFTC Commitment of Traders (IMM) data, to levels close to the lowest for the year.

Moreover, the correlation between interest rate differentials and currencies is still insignificant in most cases suggesting that even a jump in yields such as the move prompted by last week’s comments by Fed Chairman Bernanke should not automatically be expected to boost the dollar. Once markets become more aggressive in pricing in higher US interest rates this may change but there is little sign of this yet

In contrast the euro continues to benefit from recycling of central bank reserves and recorded a jump in speculative appetite close to its highest level this year according to the IMM data. Reserve flows from central banks may contribute to EUR/USD taking aim at its year high around 1.4844 (last tested on 24 September 09) over coming days.

Posted in central banks, Currencies, Economy, Interest rates, Monetary Policy, US. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Leave a Comment »
« Older posts
Newer posts »